Compost preparations
Today I would like to deal with the yarrow preparation, using it as an example to show some of the principle of the preparations, of their makeup and usage. Rudolf Steiner prepares our understanding of the yarrow preparation, and indeed all the other preparations, already in the third lecture of the Agriculture Course, This is when he speaks about the archetypal substance of life altogether: protein. The life of the animal and human kingdoms would not be possible without this archetypal substance of protein in the plant kingdom. As human beings we need to have this in order to take it in as a constituent of our food. We break it down completely in our intestinal digestion. This active breakdown of well-structured protein from outside enables us to build up our own protein. It is not the substance of the protein that is of any value, but its pattern. Its specific structure delivers a kind of model, which we perceive especially with the liver while the protein is broken down. In fact there are four organ systems that are involved in perceiving the protein pattern and they are able, in so doing, to build up our individual human protein. These are the kidney system, the lung system, the liver system and the heart system. All four are able to build up substantiality as it were, out of nothing, yet with the basis of the form pattern, this highly individualised protein. This is the reason why this archetypal creation has to take place first in the outside world, in the plant kingdom. Four elements correspond to these four organ systems within us: carbon (kidney), oxygen (lung), nitrogen (liver) and hydrogen (heart). These four elements, together with sulphur, constitute protein. In the Agriculture course Rudolf Steiner calls them four (respectively five) sisters. They are also broadly distributed in the outer world. We breath nitrogen (79% of the air is nitrogen); we breath oxygen; we find carbon in coal, sulphur in an elemental state, and hydrogen is everywhere. All these elements are carriers of forces. Carbon is the carrier of formative forces, oxygen of life forces, nitrogen of astral or sentient forces, hydrogen is close to the physical and relates at the same time to the spiritual world. It is the carrier of the forces that are released from the physical world into the cosmos. In contrast to hydrogen, sulphur is the mediator of the spiritual within the earthly realm. In the outer world these elements are more or less separate from one another. So it is a mystery how to combine especially the four elements, carbon, oxygen, hydrogen and nitrogen. In the plant kingdom this involves two substances that are polar opposites: sulphur and potassium. Thus we see that protein is formed when the three principles that were once well known in alchemy are equally at work: the salt principle potassium and related elements- the sulphur principle, and in between the mediating mercury principle the basic constituents of protein. Sulphur and potassium being representatives and carriers of cosmic and earthly influences help the mercurial archetype, the proteins, to come into being.
Whilst speaking about protein Rudolf Steiner introduces the compost preparations and refers to the mystery of how protein comes about in the right way in the outside world. He says there is one most miraculous plant which can be seen as a model for all the other plants, in the way it handles the sulphur and potassium process with regard to the formation of the archetypal creation of protein. He characterises this miraculous plant, the yarrow (Achillea millefolium), from the point of view of spiritual research and I would like to read his description [1]. He says of arrow:
" Take a plant which is generally obtainable. If there is none in the district, you can use the dried herb just as well. Yarrow is indeed miraculous creation. No doubt every plant is so; but if you afterwards look at any other plant, you will take it to heart all the more, what a marvel this yarrow is. It contains that of which I told you that the spirit always moistens its fingers therewith when it wants to carry the different constituents as carbon, nitrogen, etc. to their several organic places. Yarrow stands out in nature as though some creator of the plant world had had it before him as a model, to show him how to bring the sulphur into a right relation to the remaining substances of the plant.
"One would fain say, 'In no other plant do the nature spirits attain such perfection in the use of sulphur as they do in yarrow." (It is very interesting that Rudolf Steiner mentions the nature spirits at this point, and it is the only place in the Agriculture course where he does so). "And if you also know of the working of yarrow in the animal or human organism if you know how well it can make good all that is due to weaknesses of the astral body (provided it is rightly carried into the biological sphere) - then you will trace it still farther, in its yarrow-nature, throughout the entire process of plant growth."
Spiritual Science widens our view and so first of all we should look at whether the yarrow reveals some of its miraculous nature in its outer form. When looking for yarrow, we see that its natural environment follows human civilisation. It appears in the open plains where sun and earth meet directly, in meadows which are only cut once -not so much in permanently grazed pastures along the roadsides and field borders; in an open area where sun and earth meet directly. We find yarrow more in dry than wet areas, more in loamy than sandy soils, and more in sunny than shady places. When we observe the plant itself, we see that the yarrow germinates in spring time and first forms a rosette. The leaves are pressed flat to the ground. All of a sudden, usually around the middle of June -this depends on the region of course - it shoots up very quickly and forms the first flower buds. Normally the yarrow blossoms during June, July and August, when the earth-cosmos relationship is at its utmost. But we can often see the yarrow flowering in September, October and even into November. When it wilts in late autumn or winter, what is left? We see the ligneous, solidified stems gathered in clumps all over the meadows which give the image of very sturdy plants.
Looking at the leaves, a real metamorphosis is visible. Although the leaves split up from a midrib and almost disperse towards the periphery into a range of leaf stems that fan out into tiny little spears, they show a complete leaf blade. The manifold pinnation ending up in points and spears very much relates to a strong sulphur activity. If we observe these points and spears in greater detail with magnifying glass we find astonishingly an almost succulent shape. This points to a strong potassium activity. The bottom leaves show a fairly long stalk and a well-developed longish stretched blade. Further upwards the stalk becomes shorter and shorter, the blade broadens into an oval shape. Coming nearer to the flower the stalk disappears, the leaf reaches towards the stem. In the end the stalk becomes more lanceolate. It envelops the stem with its finely formed spears. So the leaves show a real metamorphosis. They are quite astonishingly dark green and very smooth, which in a certain sense contradicts the extremely pinnate form. If you taste the yarrow leaves they are very sharp and bitter at the base, and become more aromatic the higher you go towards the blossom.
Looking at the blossom we see the stem splitting into the umbrella shaped flower. It does not have a very distinctive, out-raying face as some other flowers do. It is rather more concentrated in itself and gives the impression almost of dried flower. It is white, sometimes pink, in a colour, but not very shiny, as if it would hold back some of its powerful force. The whole umbrella is composed of many flower baskets (umbels), which are formed of tiny little blossoms (pedicles). So the yarrow is truly a typical manifestation of the compositae family; its nature reveals an enormous differentiation (sulphur) and concentration (potassium). at the same time a great
One could say we have defined a polarity in the yarrow. On the one hand we have this sturdiness of the stem, with a strong lignifying tendency which causes them to last so long (one can often see them standing in the meadows the following year) and at the same time soft, dark green velvety and apparently succulent leaves. On the other hand there is a very highly developed flower and enormous segmentation of the leaves. This polarity of an earthly and cosmic influence can also be observed if we look at the roots. Of course they normally cannot be seen, belonging as they do in the darkness of the earth. But in the last decades much emphasis has been laid on root morphology. The yarrow roots are quite extraordinary, with many thin threads going down very deeply into the earth, like a stream. Again there is an inner activity, a motion, like in the leaves, but at the same time they are so firmly bound in the soil that it is almost impossible to pull up a yarrow plant. So there is the movement of the roots flowing down into the earth, but at the same time a steadfastness like in the stem. In autumn and winter, just below the surface, the stolons form runners which then produce new shoots early in the spring. Therefore we often find patches of these stoloniferous yarrows in open pastures.
The yarrow reveals the polarity of earthly and cosmic forces in a very distinct way. Its outer appearance is remarkable manifestation of the forces which its own being sends into the earthly realm in order to build up, supported by earthly forces and substances, this image of its being. What we perceive is not a reality, it is an image. The forces that build up this image are real, but imperceptible. They originate in the cosmic and earthly realm and are directed by the true being of the yarrow, which remains in the spiritual sphere. It is important to realise that what we see is an image, an illusion. But it points to a spiritual reality which works through two principles. One can be described as shaping the yarrow according to its cosmic archetypal form, causing that which brings about differentiation of the leaves and flowers, the scent, taste and colour of any of its organs and also its fragrance. We may call this the sulphur principle. On the other hand we have pointed to a diversified root system, the sturdy stem, the strong turgor pressure causing succulence of the pinnate leaves very similar to the round shape of the growing point. All these phenomena are caused by what we call the salt or rather the potassium principle. The latter gives the plant its outer earthly appearance, the sulphur principle governs the cosmic archetype they manifest. Affirming this polarity we may better understand why Rudolf Steiner, when speaking about the herbs that particular herbs are used for the preparations, speaks about in relation to certain earthly elements. In the case of the yarrow he speaks about the potassium and the wonderful, quantitative relationship between potassium and sulphur with regard to protein formation. He refers to this unique content of sulphur in yarrow in relationship to its ability to work with potassium as being an ideal model within the plant kingdom. We must therefore now ask, what is the nature of potassium, where does it occur? We find potassium as an essential constituent all over the mineral kingdom, especially in mica, feldspar and therefore in great quantities in granite but also widely distributed as a salt. It is quite interesting that the quantity of potassium relates strongly to the quantity of silica in the earth's crust. The more silica there is, normally the more potassium can also be found there. Potassium is really an earthly element. I would call it the representative of the earthly realm altogether. It is, as all physical substances, submitted to physical, calculable laws which we can study in physics and chemistry. If we make an experiment and dissolve a potassium salt, for example potassium chloride, in water it will completely disappear in its crystallised state and dissolve. The property of the water will have changed according to the quantity of dissolved salt. When we then heat the water until it evaporates the salt is again formed, in exactly the same quantity and crystal structure. The laws of the physical realm finite and liable to are calculability. From this point of view it is justified to say the physical earthly realm is dead. It is highly disconnected from its spiritual origin. But potassium stands out through yet another property. It is 0.001% radioactive as it occurs in the earth's crust: it underlies a decay. What does this signify? Potassium is a physical substance at the border of the sub-natural world, the sub-sensory world. From beyond the border there are beings actively exposing the forces of electricity, magnetism and nuclear energy to nature. The nature of potassium as the representative of the salt-forming elements can be understood to be a link to sub-nature, marking the border, as it were. In contrast to it is sulphur substance the spirit “moistens its fingers with" the representative of those elements that are the link with the supersensory, the supernatural world, with the cosmos. So we find yarrow is a revelation of a very strong interaction of an extreme polarity. The interacting poles of sulphur and potassium as they occur in yarrow seem to be the fundamental basis for the ideal formation of protein.
The yarrow, like any other plant, takes in potassium by the roots. There the potassium as an earthly substance, with all its properties we have described above disappears. It leaves its physical environment and enters a living one. Of course we may find potassium to a certain extent still in a salty state in the roots. But in the process of growing and developing in the first still watery leaves and all the more in the successive ones, the potassium becomes estranged from its physical properties and instead takes on properties step by step that relate to the living. Within the living sphere it become a carrier of Living forces: the result of these work in the formation of tissue, the scaffolding of the plant culminating in the lignifying tendency, and on the other hand in the swelling, succulent appearance. If you have a deficiency of potassium in soil and plant, on a very hot day the leaves tend to hang down. Evaporation in even increased because the stomata do not close properly. Their regulation and likewise the pressure of the juice in the calls, the so-called turgor pressure, is a function of potassium in the living context. Down in the roots the potassium still has salty properties: The further it comes up in the stem participating in the formation of the sequence of the leaves, it begins to be under the guidance of the sulphur, and is step by step potentized towards the blossom in the sense of a continuous estrangement tram its physical properties, its being bound in space. A real potentization takes place in the process of time, that is in life as I described yesterday. The metamorphosis of the plant is an outer image of the potentization of potassium and its related earthly elements within the course of the full unfolding of the plant. The further up we look in the plant from stage to stage, the more the potassium loses its definable physical properties and becomes a carrier of living cosmic forces, which are unquantifiable.
It no longer marke the border to the sub-natural world, it has been lifted towards the border of the supersensory world by the sulphur process. This is the mystery that takes place within the plant, in each different species in a highly specialised way. Yarrow is specially qualified to master the potassium-sulphur process in favour of an ideal formation of protein, the mercurial result of this functional polarity.
Here potassium is no longer detectable in the plant by means of chemical analysis. Of course we can find potassium again if we burn the plant to ashes, but then the plant is dead and what we obtain is salt. We cannot detect the potassium in the very state to which it is raised in the living sphere. The possibility of detecting radioactively marked elements in the living plant is not a counter-proof. It only shows that plant life is submitted to the conditions of its environment, as becomes manifest in the dangerous pesticide residues and other contamination frequently found.
Plant-life can either be weakened - it is then less able to estrange elements from their physically bound properties, especially the sub-natural properties - or it can be strengthened. This is a matter of appropriate manuring: a matter of dealing with the yarrow preparation for instance. It is impossible to detect the gradual transformation of potassium by the sulphur process through analysis. It comes to the utmost of dilution and potentisation, where the plant ceases to grow, where the flower develops. The question is, how are we able to give permanence to this culmination of plant growth, the flowering stage? Because the very moment the flower appears, it fades away. It cannot perpetuate itself, it just lasts a moment: it is a kind of status nascendi, the full opening of the flower towards the cosmos. Looking at the flowering stage of the plant we can make two observations. One is that the being of the yarrow appears as an image in its perfection in the flower, in the shape, colour and fragrance, but in the unfolding of the flower it comes to an end. The plant dies into the flower. There it is touched from outside by its higher being, which was at work all the time throughout the growing process. On the other hand we
can observe this gesture of the flower opening towards the cosmos. We must learn to inwardly follow this gesture with our thinking and feeling: we might approach it with an expression of total openness, devotion and willingness. Observing the flower we again meet a polarity. On the one hand the sulphur process, supported by the potassium process coming to an end in space and time in the blossom, leads to a perfect image of the true plant being. On the other hand if we follow the potassium process from the earth upwards, supported by the sulphur process, it begins in the dead state of salt, ending up in this infinite openness and a gesture of willingless will. This gesture of willingless will signifies an embryonic state to which, in my opinion, Rudolf Steiner is referring when he speaks about the plant releasing germinal forces into the etheric world [2].
The blossom fades away. Therefore the question arises, how can we preserve that which has come to an end and that which hides the potential of a new beginning in the blossom? How can we preserve that very moment before it fades away? There are three possible transformations to which the blossom may be submitted. One ends in seed formation. All the processes in the blossom are yet undetermined. It rays out its shining colour, its fragrance and aromatic substances, but the very moment seed formation takes place, all processes are determined to serve the newly formed germ. The seed has just to fall to earth and the new plant will shoot up. The second transformation of the fading flower is when it falls to the ground and underlies humus formation. Rudolf Steiner points to the third transformation, as mentioned above. It is the surplus germinal forces which vanish from the flower into the etheric world and become the substance for a future macrocosm. Our question is, how to give permanence flowering stage before these transformations take place? to the I think that Rudolf Steiner had this question in mind when he indicates the first step of making the yarrow preparation. The answer cannot be found in the plant kingdom. We must search for an answer in the higher, animal kingdom. We must find a technique, as it were, to lift the flower beyond its natural limitation, over a threshold onto a higher level, onto the level of astral effectiveness, which is present in the animal kingdom. The soul being of the animal has incarnated into space and time. All its organs are formed out of forces which work into the physical and living realm from beyond space and time. The plant is merely touched by such forces from outside; " the spirit moistened its fingers with the sulphur" and shapes the plant from the outside, while the animal is inwardly permeated by its astral being. Astral forces of the animal sculpt its organs into the stream of life and endow it with the ability to function in permanence. So we must seek on a higher level to find an answer to our question. We must look for an organisation to which the yarrow, as a medicinal plant, has a healing relationship. Rudolf Steiner says the yarrow "can make good all that is due to weaknesses of the astral body". Its healing force is very much related to all processes that take place in the renal system. In order to preserve the very moment of the unfolding of the yarrow flower, Rudolf Steiner recommends us to take the bladder of a Red deerstag. We will see why later. The first step of making the preparation is to gather the flowers and stuff them into the sheath, this spherical stag's bladder. This step is one of inversion for the yarrow. Previously the yarrow flower was open to the farthest cosmos. Now it is exposed to the astral forces that are working into and within this sphere of the animal sheath. Before the yarrow flower exposed itself in a willing gesture, the potassium process was potentised upwards into a germinal state. Now, within the stag's bladder, this substantial germ becomes the carrier of the astral forces which are transmitted and concentrated in the flower by the bladder. A complete inversion is performed. An outside process, which cannot proceed out of itself, becomes an inner process, the beginning of something quite new. But what about the bladder? It is an organ of concentration, of substances which derive from the inner ensouled life of the animal. It is impregnated with the experiences which the animal had in its soul. They are drawn out of the blood stream by the kidneys and are released and concentrated in the bladder. It is an organ of excretion, very much aligned to the kidneys. The renal/bladder system is related to the most alert of the sense organs, to the eye. This fact can easily be observed, for instance, if you enter a cowhouse a bit abruptly. The cows, slightly shocked out of their dreaming perception, stare at you and within a very short time you hear a rush and a 'pat, pat pat' as they excrete their manure. The cow perceives you, but her response is not an intellectual one. She does not recognise you and respond to you with her head but with her metabolism. Her consciousness is in the rear, where the response from her soul being appears not as a spiritual recognition, because the animal has no ego, but as a physical excretion. Now we see how closely related the kidney/bladder system is to what we perceive with our eyes. The eye is the polar opposite to the kidney in its function. The bladder concentrates substances from the wide range of the inner life of the animal and excretes it to the outside world. The eye concentrates the content of unlimited perception from the outside world and then excretes it, as it were as a picture, into the inner life of the soul.
We take the bladder and the yarrow blossoms, both of which are completely disjointed from their origins. The blossoms are disjointed from
the relationship earth-cosmos, from the natural life of the plant, and the bladder is disjointed from the reality of the organism of the animal. The blossoms are internalised, and the bladder, having been inside the animal, now becomes an object in the outer world. They are inverted.
Why do we use the bladder of the stag? Studying the Agriculture Course in this respect we may discover two aspects between which we have to distinguish. The bladder, especially of the stag, is an image of the whole cosmos, in its spherical form. So firstly we have to consider the form principle. The other aspect is that Rudolf Steiner refers to the special material substance of the bladder. It is formed out of the inner activity of this very sensory-active animal. A powerful stream of perceptions of the present effective cosmic-earthly environment enters its head and condenses to the material substance of the opposite pole, the metabolic region. Observe a stag or any deer. Its nervous alert eyes, its mighty antlers stretching out and growing as long bones through the skull, it is as if the whole being of this animal expands far beyond its head into the bright surrounding world. So secondly we have to consider the substance principle. The form is a replica of achievements from the past. All animals are a replica of the wisdom of the past, but in contrast the material substance is formed and built up by forces at work in the present. What happens when we put the yarrow blossoms into the stag's bladder and expose it to the spherical form and substance of the sheath? My personal answer is that the bladder, having been emancipated from its metabolic function in the animal organism, from the substantial aspect now becomes a sense organ itself, a kind of eye which perceives, transmits and concentrates into the yarrow flowers the astral forces working in the cosmic surroundings. Whilst the spherical form of the sheath enveloping the yarrow flowers and endowed with astral forces, preserves them and gives them permanence.
Proceeding to the second step of making the preparation, we take the spheres and hang them up above the earth, in the air and warmth, so to speak into the belly of the agricultural individuality where the expansion forces are at their strongest. We do this at the time when the elements of air and warmth and the light and warmth ethers are at their most active, in the summer. In the third step we bury the spheres in the soil in the elements of water and earth. We do this during wintertime when the greatest contraction forces are at work in the head of our agricultural individuality and when the chemical and life ether are active, independent of being bound up in plant growth. The present cosmos works vertically above and below the earth in the elements of warmth, air, water and the solid earth, that is in space, and it works in time, as it were horizontally, during the seasons. So by exposing the bladder to these elements vertically in space and horizontally in time, it and its ingredients are endowed with etheric and astral forces of the present activity and revelations of the spiritual world. The flower of the yarrow, having been without will, is now raised beyond its natural limitation and ability to become the carrier of the will forces.
What happens during this second and third step of preparation making, whilst they are exposed to the elements? I already mentioned that, in the first stage, the potassium is taken up by the root and potentised right up to the blossom. This process cannot proceed any further. The blossom fades away and ends up in seed and humus formation. The first step of preparation-making has been to lift the potassium process, which has entered into a kind of germinal state in the flower, reflected in its willing gesture, beyond the threshold onto a higher stage. That happened enveloped in the stag's bladder. It created the potential to proceed to a new beginning. In the second and third steps of making the preparation this mere potential is being fulfilled by the spiritual forces working within the elements throughout the seasons in space and time. This means that the potassium is not only estranged from its physical properties and enlivened by the plant, but it is now open to be endowed with inwardness. This is my understanding of the aim of all the preparations; that physical substances are enlivened. Rudolf Steiner speaks about the aim of manuring: that it is to enliven the solid earthly itself. This can only be achieved if the physical substance is permanently enlivened. This is not the case in the plant. It dies continuously into form. The plant keeps the substantial process alive by growing on and on and by forming leaf after leaf. This cannot proceed in the blossom. In order to give the life process permanence it must be endowed with inwardness. This is what the animal can teach it. Its soul being keeps its life process streaming. when it was
Looking at the three processes of preparation making we can say that the potassium is lifted through three stages of estrangement of its physical properties, from the border of the sub-natural, via the life process of the yarrow, to being endowed with forces of inwardness. If we try to follow this thought we might discover what Rudolf Steiner actually means when he discusses the work of the first group of compost preparations, the yarrow, camomile and stinging nettle preparations. He mentions that they are related to one another in generating nitrogen of a yet unknown, completely new quality in the soil. Together they are able to transform the representation of real earthly substances, calcium, potassium, and related elements step by step, into something similar to nitrogen, and finally into real nitrogen.
What is nitrogen? Rudolf Steiner points to it being the carrier of the astral forces. In whatever context nitrogen occurs in nature it is related to some astral event, to forces of inwardness. That nitrogen is an essential element of protein only goes to show that astral forces are already involved in building up the fundamental living substance. Normally nitrogen appears in the atmosphere (79%) above the earth, being the main constituent of the
This nitrogen is an evolutionarily completed, dead physical substance. It derives from the past, being the carrier of the Old Moon wisdom. All revelations of nature and the wisdom in it are due to the existence of nitrogen. One could say that it is a physical representation of what comes to us from the past. But with our yarrow, camomile and stinging nettle preparations we are producing a new kind of nitrogen, out of substances marking the border to the sub-natural world. We lift them out of their physical dead state to become permanently enlivened and thus transformed into a new substance which we may call nitrogen because it is a carrier of a new kind of inwardness, of an astrality that works from the future into the present. A new nitrogen is formed which does not relate to the past but to the future. I would say that the goal of all the preparation work is to enliven physical substances to become receptive to forces working from the future into the present. This opens the gate to a new evolution, or shall we say involution, into the future. The only being on earth that is able to have an active relationship to the future is the human being. All other beings represent an evolutionary end. They can no longer evolve out of themselves. I don't want to enter the debate at this point about the present materialistic concept of evolution and its reflection in the theory and technique of gene engineering. The soul body of the animal is more or less body bound. It lives out its past. The plant derives from the past, but appears in the present as a true image of the present earthly cosmic relationship. The mineral kingdom has already fallen out of evolution in the past. From this point of view it is up to us, up to our freedom, what kind of future development we will give to the earth. But when we guide a substance from the mineral kingdom through the plant kingdom into the astral realm, we enable it to become a carrier of future forces. Calcium, potassium and similar elements acquire an inwardness which, according to my understanding, is what Rudolf Steiner means when he indicates that they are transformed into this new substance of nitrogen. So biodynamic farming actually means that we take over the responsibility for the earth, not by just working in such a way that we continue what is there. This happens in ecological farming. But we need to endow what is there with future forces, so the earth itself can participate in the future development of mankind.
These aspects relate very much to what we eat. If we just eat what is there, the finished process in seed and fruit formation no longer provides adequate human nutrition. Our task is to change the inner quality of protein, this arch-creation of nature, together with our own development into the future. In order to do so we need to have such preparations, the summit of manuring, by which a new kind of nitrogen participates in protein formation. Therefore quite a new quality of food will come about. This is of great significance, but it is secondary. As a precondition it is more important that we endow nature with evolutionary processes as such.
I am very glad that we have the opportunity to talk about these far-reaching aspects here, seeking for a spiritual understanding of what we are aiming at with the preparations, although it is not an easy approach. I believe that to make such an attempt is justifiable due to the close proximity of the end of the century. It is almost 70 years after the Agriculture course was held. If we at the same time work with the preparations practically, then we have another sphere of experience. Being involved willingly we create within ourselves the 'soil' wherein these Images that we are trying to develop by thinking can germinate. I think it is through this inner relationship that a deeper understanding will increasingly come about. What we urgently need is such an understanding. It is the only source of renewal for the biodynamic work and movement.
References.
[1] Agriculture, a Course of lectures by Rudolf Steiner, 1924. Pub. BDAA London 1977. See lecture 5.
[2] Steiner, R., Anthroposophical Leading Thoughts 1924-25. Pub. Rudolf Steiner Press, London 1985. Also see Lecture 1.